Good Vibes Only: Your Guide To Choosing The Right Branding Designer

When investing in a brand identity, choosing the right branding designer is essential for success. But it can be very intimidating and overwhelming to find the right person. You line up a bunch of meetings with various branding designers you find online, but after a full day on zoom meetings they all start to been together, and what was supposed to be an exciting step in your business suddenly feels like speed dating gone wrong.

There are so many branding designers out there claiming to be "experts" — how can you tell who truly has the chops to back up their claims? This comprehensive guide will help you evaluate and select a branding designer who can not only design a logo that looks good, but lead you through a valuable brand strategy process and deliver a comprehensive brand identity that you can build your entire business on.

Look Beyond Niche Experience

Many business owners initially search for branding designers with specific experience in their industry. While this approach seems logical, it may actually limit the creative potential of the project. Here's why:

The Pitfall of Ultra-Specialized Branding Designers

Branding designers who work exclusively within one, narrow niche (such as "wedding photographers" or "candle makers") often develop formulaic approaches. It may seem counter-intuitive but the truth is when a branding designer narrows their focus solely on one type of client, they tend to fall into comfortable patterns and routines. This specialization can lead to designs that feel recycled or derivative, lacking the fresh perspective that comes from diverse experience.

The danger in this approach is that your brand may end up looking remarkably similar to your competitors. While there's comfort in familiarity, the purpose of branding is to help your business stand out, not blend in. A branding designer who has only worked in your specific niche may struggle to think beyond the conventional solutions they've used repeatedly.

The Value of Diverse Experience

Instead, consider branding designers with experience across various industries. These professionals bring a wealth of cross-pollinated ideas and solutions that can give your brand a unique edge. A designer with broad experience understands how to apply fundamental design principles to any industry while bringing fresh perspectives from other sectors.

Here at Happyland Creative, our niche is small businesses but within that niche we've worked with all kinds of brands—everything from skincare to pet products, coffee to construction companies. Are we experts within each of those fields? Absolutely not. But the principles of brand design are applicable to all industries. It's not a branding designer's job to know every nuance of your specific industry, it's their job to know how to apply the principles of branding to your unique business.

This diversity of experience often leads to more innovative solutions. For example, a branding designer who has worked with both luxury retail brands and industrial companies might bring unexpected elegance to a manufacturing brand (a great example of this is our work with Quartz Impressions), or practical functionality to a high-end retail experience. The ability to think beyond industry conventions often results in more memorable, unique and therefore effective brand identities.

Can Your Branding Designer Walk The Walk?

Portfolio Assessment

A branding designer's portfolio is their visual resume, but it needs to be more than just aesthetically pleasing. When reviewing portfolios, look beyond surface-level beauty to understand the strategic thinking behind each project. Ask your potential branding designer what their favorite project was and why, or how they ended up arriving at a design that you find particularly interesting.

Strong portfolios demonstrate versatility in style and approach, showing that the designer can adapt to different brand personalities rather than forcing every client into the same visual box. Look for case studies or project descriptions that explain the business challenges each brand faced and how the design solutions addressed them.

Pay particular attention to before-and-after examples when available (some branding designers may not display before images within their public portfolio, but you can always ask for them privately). These transformations can reveal how well the designer understands business objectives and translates them into visual solutions.

Questions You Can Ask:

• What was your strategic approach for [specific project in their portfolio]?
• Can you walk me through a challenging project and how you solved it?
• How did this rebrand impact the client's business?
• What metrics or results can you share from past projects?
• How do you ensure each brand design is unique to the client?
• Can you share examples of brands you've designed in my industry or similar ones?

Process and Strategy

The strongest brand designers approach their work as strategic problem-solvers first and foremost, rather than just visual artists. Their process should begin with thorough research and discovery, understanding not just what a business does, but why it exists and who it serves. Having a deep understanding of a brand's audience, customer base, and business goals is the ultimate key to creating a brand identity that suits them perfectly.

A great branding designer will have a clearly defined process that includes:

Research and Discovery Phase: This crucial first step involves understanding the business, its market position, target audience, and competitors. This research forms the foundation for all design decisions.

Strategy Development: Based on research findings, the designer should develop a strategic framework that guides visual choices. This might include brand positioning, personality attributes, and key messaging points.

Design Exploration: Only after establishing strategic direction should the designer begin creating visual concepts. These concepts should clearly connect back to the strategy and business objectives.

Implementation and Guidelines: The final phase should include clear documentation of how to use the new brand identity consistently across all touchpoints. For some businesses (especially smaller ones) a few visual examples and basic guidelines may be all that's necessary, while for larger businesses a more robust brand guidelines book may be needed.

Questions You Can Ask:

• What does your branding design process look like from start to finish?
• How do you research a client's industry and target audience?
• How do you incorporate business goals into your design decisions?
• What strategic frameworks do you use for brand development?
• How do you ensure the brand strategy aligns with business objectives?
• What deliverables can I expect throughout the process?

Finding A Branding Designer To Match Your Vibe

It cannot be understated how important communication is throughout the brand design process. A branding designer's job is to take a bunch of vague and verbal and/or written communication and translate it into visual communication. This doesn't happen through mind reading but rather open, honest, helpful feedback between client and designer.

It's essential that you can comfortably communicate with the branding designer you select. Here are Happyland we use the word "vibe" a lot. You need to make sure you vibe with your branding designer. This kind of personal chemistry often isn't formulaic and can be very subjective. Even if someone checks off all the boxes, the vibe, for whatever reason, may be off and it's important to take that into consideration. Strategic branding design is about creating an identity, a personality, for your business. It's important to work working closely and have good communication with the branding designer you select.

Communication Style

The success of a branding project often hinges on effective collaboration between client and designer. Strong communication skills are just as important as design talent. Your branding designer should demonstrate clear, proactive communication from the first interaction.

This includes setting clear expectations about timelines, deliverables, and the feedback process. They should be able to articulate their design decisions in business terms, not just aesthetic ones. Watch for how they handle questions and feedback – do they listen actively and respond thoughtfully, or do they become defensive?

Questions You Can Ask:

• How do you prefer to communicate with clients during projects?
• What is your typical response time for emails or messages?
• How do you handle revision requests and feedback?
• What project management tools do you use?
• How often can I expect project updates?
• What do you need from me to ensure the project stays on track?

Chemistry and Compatibility

While often overlooked, the personal dynamic between client and designer can significantly impact project success. The best brand identity projects are true collaborations, requiring trust, communication, and mutual respect between both parties.

During initial conversations, notice how well the designer listens and whether they ask thoughtful questions about your business. Are they genuinely curious about your goals and challenges? Do they share your values and understand your vision? Are you comfortable having a conversation with them? Do you feel like they are guiding you through the process or like you are going to have to guide them through it?

Consider their working style and how it aligns with yours. Some designers take a more formal, structured approach, while others might be more flexible and informal. Neither is inherently better, but compatibility with your preferences can make the process more enjoyable and productive.

Questions You Can Ask:

• What types of clients do you most enjoy working with?
• How would you describe your design style and philosophy?
• What values guide your design practice?
• How do you handle disagreements or creative differences?
• What makes a client relationship successful in your experience?
• Can you share an example of a particularly successful client collaboration?

Red Flags to Watch For When Selecting a Branding Designer

Sometimes, knowing what to avoid is as important as knowing what to look for. Be wary of brand designers who show these warning signs:

Vague Process: A professional designer should have a clear, well-defined process they can easily explain. If they're unable to articulate their approach or seem to "wing it," this could indicate lack of experience or professionalism.

Poor Communication: Watch for delayed responses, unclear explanations, or defensive reactions to questions. These early communication issues often worsen during the project.

Inconsistent Portfolio: If a designer's work varies wildly in quality or style, this might indicate they're still developing their skills or haven't found their specialty.

Unrealistic Promises: Be cautious of brand designers who promise extremely quick turnarounds or guarantee specific business results. Brand design is a nuanced process that requires adequate time and can't guarantee specific outcomes.

Lack of Confidence: While your input and ideas should be considered during a brand identity design, you're hiring a brand designer for their expertise. If your potential branding designer is constantly looking to you to tell them what they need to do, you're going to find yourself feeling frustrated and less than confident in the outcome. Look for a branding designer who is open to constructive feedback, but won't add glitter just because you asked them to.

Making the Final Decision

Selecting the right branding designer is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of multiple factors. While portfolio quality is certainly important, it shouldn't be the only decision factor.

Consider the full picture:

Strategic Thinking: How well does the designer understand business objectives and translate them into design solutions?

Communication and Process: Do they have a clear, professional approach to project management and client collaboration?

Experience Level: Do they have experience with projects of similar scope and complexity to yours?

Chemistry: Do their values and working style align well with yours and is it easy to converse with them?

The right designer will combine creative talent with business acumen, bringing both fresh perspectives and strategic thinking to your project. They should feel like a true partner in your brand's evolution, not just a service provider. Take time to thoroughly evaluate potential brand designers and trust your instincts about who will be the best partner for your brand's evolution.

Think We Might Be The Branding Designer For You?

Here at Happyland Creative, we have a thorough strategic process as well as a design process that is dialed in and proven to make your job as a client easier while giving you the best brand identity possible. The next step is to schedule a free, no-pressure call to see if we match your vibe.

‍